You honestly don't think someone has tried that approach before this person got to the point of feeling suicidal? Telling depressed people to "get over it" is just about the worst thing you can do. If they could just "get over it" (that's basically what he's saying), they probably wouldn't be here looking for support, now would they?
???
Support entails more than just telling people that everything's okay when even
they know for goddamn sure that it's not.
I'm sure someone's tried a lot of approaches. Including the ":hug: it's okay, hun. You'll get some money soon." You think someone hasn't tried that? That's not any better. Not at all. In fact, I'm pretty sure
that's the worst thing you can do, enable someone's sense of immobility. I don't think suggesting practical things is "the worst thing you can do."
I don't think there's a much better, more concise way to give down-to-earth advice in this situation... when, yes, advice
is what they asked for. (And I quote "what do i do? Im so fucking desperate...")
A reality-check is what a lot of people need, more so than the emotional subsidizing you're suggesting. Many people, as I'm sure you understand, don't think rationally when depressed/suicidal. A little bit of rationality from an outside source never hurt anyone.
Except the goal of this forum is to save lives and not necessarily to be brutally honest with everyone you speak to. And being a jerk to someone who is obviously already at rock bottom just might very well be the final straw. Ever think of that? Sometimes, honesty can wait until you're sure the person wants to hear you tell them to go away, grow up, suck it up and all that stuff.
Once again, the OP asked what s/he should do, right? Not for sympathy. That's not what the individual asked for.
Was the "grow up" thing even jerky? Hardly. Not attacking the OP or anything; it's all right to feel a little unmotivated sometimes and it happens. But damn, the question the person posed
begged for a little wake-up call.
Sometimes it's what people need to hear. I know it makes me think hard about where I am when people are blunt with their words. It makes me think a lot harder than "It's okay!" and it makes me a lot more inclined to do something about it. Hearing genuine stuff more than once can make things click, even if, initially, all you can think to respond with is "Ouch."
Gotta do what you gotta. In several cases, if you hear it enough, you'll learn to accept it. That's all.