Two of my best friends get a lot of girls. Me and the other of my 3 best friends don't. It's not that we're all that different as far as looks, athleticism or brains, and we're all nice people. But our manners are absolutely different, which is why two are successful with girls and two aren't. The two that get a lot of girls are both on spectator-sports-type teams. I'm on a nordic ski team. That sort of difference. I'm just an introverted person, (not shy, there is a difference). The 4 of us have known each other for a long, long time. And the point I wanted to make is that the two who have lots of girls after them are perfectly nice guys who have to shut down a lot of girls. There aren't any really easy ways to do it--I've been in that situation, not very many times, but enough for me to know to steer clear. Enough for me to feel sorry for my friends when I see the look in their eyes saying "I like her but not that much, somehow this is going to end badly" when we're leaving a party. They hurt girls without wanting to quite often. The most successful relationships they've been in have been "taken slow" which is, believe it or not, what a lot of guys (even ones with a lot of "experience") often want, and if those meaningful relationships ended with hurt, then at least both people thought the chance taken had still been worth it (and worth taking again).
Another thing: In my opinion, if you're really young, then it's true most of the confident guys are confident as a result of being assholes. I think that's true until people reach their early or mid-20's and start to either make something of themselves or make nothing of themselves. Women may be attracted to confident guys starting in 3rd grade, but at that point I think there's not much out there for them. I know I wasn't exactly there for them then, or in middle school, or in high school really :rolleyes: but in my opinion I'm becoming something worthwhile even though I'm a "nice guy" by reputation.
Life hasn't been too satisfying lately though... hence me being in these forums...