People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different things.

Discussion in 'Mental Health Disorders' started by anarulesmenow, Jul 27, 2011.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. anarulesmenow

    anarulesmenow Well-Known Member

    I just read an article which talked about Bipolar disorder, and some guy had commented on it saying:


    'what your describing is not really bipolar, it's manic depression.... two completely different mental illnesses. bipolar's rather tricky to describe. the most obvious symptoms are narcissism, inappropriate moods/behaviors, recklessness/fearless, and some symptoms that are common but not always present are sexual promiscuity, hallucinating, hearing voices and coming off as a real nut job so to speak. manic depression is more cycles of mania and depression. depending on what type of manic depression you have, you could suffer from more episodes of mania than depression, vice versa, or a straight up 50/50.'

    Has anyone else ever heard/read this sort of thing before?
    I found a little funny to be honest, as it seemed quite absurd for someone to think Bipolar and Manic Depression are completely different things.
     
  2. Speedy

    Speedy Staff Alumni

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    It sounds like psychobabble to me since I don't know the difference between bipolar disorder and manic depression. :D

    I guess if what he/she is saying is false information, then I guess he/she is ignorant in that regard.
     
  3. lightbeam

    lightbeam Antiquities Friend

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    I just looked up 'Manic depression' on http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, and it went to bipolar. So, maybe they are one in the same?
     
  4. houseofcards

    houseofcards Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    I've always been told they are the same, manic depression is just the scientific term.
     
  5. anarulesmenow

    anarulesmenow Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    They are the same thing. It was originally called Manic Depression, but the name was changed to Bipolar Disorder.
     
  6. Kaos General

    Kaos General Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    Erm is this thread really asking the difference between bi-polar and manic depression? Their is no difference as Manic Depression was the old name for Bi-polar disorder. Manic depression i guess could be defined as Bi-polar type I
     
  7. anarulesmenow

    anarulesmenow Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    Im not asking the difference, as there isn't one. I'm just asking if people have met people who have said there is a difference.
     
  8. Kaos General

    Kaos General Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    :lol!: they take one look at me and decide its best not to ask such questions as obvious answer is obvious. Sorry i should explain i got diagnosed with bi-polar back when it was still called manic depresssion.
     
  9. ace

    ace Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    I always thought they were the same thing.
     
  10. Butterfly

    Butterfly Pokémon Master Staff Alumni SF Author SF Supporter

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    They are the same thing. Bipolar is just the new name for manic depression as it supposedly more "politically correct".
     
  11. SashaJade

    SashaJade Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    I know this woman who says she gets manic depression every few years; But that would mean she is bipolar, which she isn't.

    People assume manic depression is acute depression, which it isn't. They are two different things.
     
  12. Growing Pains

    Growing Pains Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    I've seen it a lot. My sister didn't know they were the same thing. People generally assume that manic depression is the same as major depression. (At least, in my experience) However, once I explained it to my sister, she understood. It's not really too hard to realize that manic depression is Bipolar disorder. Frankly, to me it seems it'd be common sense. Since bipolar consists of manic episodes and depression episodes, yeah... seems like it would be common sense.
     
  13. damage.case

    damage.case Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    Some people think schizophrenia and multiple personality disorder are the same.
     
  14. bhawk

    bhawk Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    My old boss thought bipolar disorder wasnt "real" but manic depression was, as already said, bipolar is just the more recent name for manic depression
     
  15. Crue-K

    Crue-K Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    The diagnosis of Manic Depression officially changed to Bipolar Affective Disorder in 1980 when the DSM-III was published. However when I was first diagnosed in 1993, my psychiatrist called it Manic Depression. I think it was the late 90's when I was told it was now called Bipolar. There is so much ignorance and confusion regarding Bipolar, you just need to read some of the retarded answers on Yahoo Answers website.
     
  16. jdbrowni14

    jdbrowni14 Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    Manic depression is a more severe form of bipolar disorder. Cycling usually occurs every month.
     
  17. Crue-K

    Crue-K Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    No it's not, they are the same thing.
     
  18. anarulesmenow

    anarulesmenow Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    They are the same thing, although I guess before bipolar came in, manic depression would have meant something like bipolar 1, whereas with bipolar you can get bipolar 2 as well.
     
  19. anarulesmenow

    anarulesmenow Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    I personally like the term bipolar, although i would assume that less people know what it means than the term manic depression, which is more obvious. Bipolar assumes there are two poles (extreme mania and extreme depression) and in between these two poles there are many other levels e.g. hypomania, cyclothemia, mixed episodes, normal states etc.
     
  20. Slothbear

    Slothbear Well-Known Member

    Re: People who say Manic Depression and Bipolar Disorder are completely different thi

    I always thought they were the same as well.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.