• Xenforo forums over the past few months have been seeing spam posts from existing user accounts. Bots hitting forums using lists of emails/passwords leaked elsewhere. We strongly recommend that all users change their password ASAP.

Anybody with a substance abuse history try ECT?

Silverpuddle

Some kind of geek
SF Author
SF Supporter
#1
I posted a few days ago about Remeron, but I didn't have the response to it my doctor wanted, so he's already taken me off. This has left us back on square one. I've had an underwhelming response to probably 8-10 antidepressants in my life, and the only one that worked really well (Trintellix) seems to have quit. I would really like to try ECT (electroconvulsive therapy) at this point, but the psychiatrist says I can't because I don't have enough clean time. My drug of choice is alcohol and I've been sober about 2.5 months. I tried looking up why people with recent substance abuse histories can't get ECT, but there doesn't seem to be anything on the internet. I found a few pages about how nobody has studied ECT and substance abuse, as well as one study that said people with comorbid alcohol abuse did better than a control group when given ECT, one that said people who abused alcohol did about the same, and one that said alcohol abusers did less well than a control group, but still improved overall.

Sooooo yeah. No idea why I'm barred from this potentially life-saving treatment. (And before you ask: yes, I know about Post Acute Withdrawal. It does not do to people what my major depressive disorder is doing to me.)
 

Silverpuddle

Some kind of geek
SF Author
SF Supporter
#2
Well. Yeah. It also has something like a 75% success rate in dealing with treatment-resistant depression, so I really don't care how much they don't know about it. Also, there's nothing in particular in my short term memory worth preserving. ECT also doesn't "scramble neurons." Something like an egg beater might do that. ECT changes brain chemistry in ways that usually relieve depression. Not saying it's for everyone. There's just no need to be alarmist about it.
 

Trapper

Asking the right questions
#3
Well. Yeah. It also has something like a 75% success rate in dealing with treatment-resistant depression, so I really don't care how much they don't know about it. Also, there's nothing in particular in my short term memory worth preserving. ECT also doesn't "scramble neurons." Something like an egg beater might do that. ECT changes brain chemistry in ways that usually relieve depression. Not saying it's for everyone. There's just no need to be alarmist about it.
just be fully informed in your choice, and yeah it does scramble neurons. lookup and research brain holonomic theory
 

Walker

Admin
SF Social Media
SF Author
SF Supporter
#4
just be fully informed in your choice, and yeah it does scramble neurons. lookup and research brain holonomic theory
This theory is not a far reaching study, this isn't even available on any actual legit psychology sites.
Lets not spread non factual information to people who are seeking assistance. They can make informed decisions with their doctors without the added "benefit" of armchair pseudo psychology.
 

Please Donate to Help Keep SF Running

Total amount
$60.00
Goal
$255.00
Top