• IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT: Please read THIS THREAD about a rebrand for SF.

I get so tired of therapy

Jsinjin

SF Supporter
#1
I don’t like trying to figure out why I feel some way or what I should do. Therapy always seems to me to be some sort of auditor rather than guidance. The goal is to get me to figure things out for myself. But I’ve been down a long time. I’m starting to feel like the potential solutions are just a random bunch of hopes that something I come up with works.

“why do I think I have a feeling that I have no value?” I say it to myself all the time “I have no value”.

I feel like this is kind of like that engineering 5 whys in quality assurance: the space shuttle blew up. Why? The explosive gases caught fire. why? The o ring failed, why? It had poor chemical characteristics Why? The actual bonds between the rubber were not strong enough to maintain that pressure at low temperature. Why? Because quantum mechanical bond processes come allow overlap of that level of strength in a thiolated diene polymer why?

you can keep asking but at some point the answer is not in my level of expertise and I don’t think anyone can answer ir

same thing with me: why do you think you keep feeling like you have no value: because I dislike the value of the things I do and how i interact with others: why do you think that is? I suppose I can say “it came to me in a dream”

I once hurt my shoulder. Pretty bad. I was having trouble even putting my seatbelt on. I didn’t go to the doctor and have him ask me why I thought my shoulder hurt. Nor did the physical therapist expect me to navigate the best way to rehab and in 8 weeks I was moving back to normal. I think if I had done it all myself guesssimg what the problem was and what I should try to rehab it, I would still be hurt. Which is sort of what I think about therapy.
And I hate the mantra of “we want you do learn to help yourself”. Again, the orthopedic doc didn’t treat me that way with my injury. They took an x ray and MRI and diagnosed the problem and recommended a course of treatment.
This is more like a 1980s choose your own adventure paperback of “guess what you should try next tk feel better”
 
#2
I'm sorry therapy hasn't helped. Therapy seems to work well for some people, especially if there is something they really want to express to a therapist, or if there is something valuable that they learn from the therapist.

It's also true that if you don't fit into those categories, therapy typically proves useless or counterproductive.

It's typical that meds and therapy are the first things that get offered to someone, but when they're not working imho it's better to try other things.
 

JeiJie

Active Member
#3
I'm glad someone put this into words. I felt the exact same way when I took a few sessions a little while ago. It seems like it is expected of everyone to do and that it is a catch all for every problem. And if you run into any issues or just flat out hate it? Just keep going anyway! I found myself getting more and more frustrated, and feeling worse and worse after each session, even after confronting the therapist.

If I have to figure everything out for myself, then why am I paying you to be here?
 
#4
And if you run into any issues or just flat out hate it? Just keep going anyway!
Imho, it's relevant that therapists make their living by providing therapy. I'd like to think that therapists always prioritize the best interests of their patients over their own self interests, but it's not always the case.
 

JeiJie

Active Member
#5
Imho, it's relevant that therapists make their living by providing therapy. I'd like to think that therapists always prioritize the best interests of their patients over their own self interests, but it's not always the case.
Yeah, I can't fault a professional for recommending their practice. My gripe is more with everyone else insisting that it's for everyone, despite it being a common sentiment that it takes years to find the right therapist and methodology. I think it stems from the fact that therapy is the default recommendation anyone can give. And those that did not benefit from it feel ashamed for not sticking it out or not trying hard enough for long enough.

The therapist I saw was kind and well intentioned, but it was obvious that I was getting frustrated and she was floundering towards our last few sessions, unsure of how to proceed. I think I would have respected her more if she was more up front in the fact that she couldn't help me, instead of stringing me along.
 
#6
The therapist I saw was kind and well intentioned
Imho it's better than someone intentionally milking you for cash, but her therapy still caused problems.
My gripe is more with everyone else insisting that it's for everyone
Yeah, that's a problem. Therapy is a stock answer. It's great for some people but it's not sufficiently acknowledged that it doesn't work for everyone.
 

another world

Well-Known Member
#7
I don’t like trying to figure out why I feel some way or what I should do. Therapy always seems to me to be some sort of auditor rather than guidance. The goal is to get me to figure things out for myself. But I’ve been down a long time. I’m starting to feel like the potential solutions are just a random bunch of hopes that something I come up with works.

“why do I think I have a feeling that I have no value?” I say it to myself all the time “I have no value”.

I feel like this is kind of like that engineering 5 whys in quality assurance: the space shuttle blew up. Why? The explosive gases caught fire. why? The o ring failed, why? It had poor chemical characteristics Why? The actual bonds between the rubber were not strong enough to maintain that pressure at low temperature. Why? Because quantum mechanical bond processes come allow overlap of that level of strength in a thiolated diene polymer why?

you can keep asking but at some point the answer is not in my level of expertise and I don’t think anyone can answer ir

same thing with me: why do you think you keep feeling like you have no value: because I dislike the value of the things I do and how i interact with others: why do you think that is? I suppose I can say “it came to me in a dream”

I once hurt my shoulder. Pretty bad. I was having trouble even putting my seatbelt on. I didn’t go to the doctor and have him ask me why I thought my shoulder hurt. Nor did the physical therapist expect me to navigate the best way to rehab and in 8 weeks I was moving back to normal. I think if I had done it all myself guesssimg what the problem was and what I should try to rehab it, I would still be hurt. Which is sort of what I think about therapy.
And I hate the mantra of “we want you do learn to help yourself”. Again, the orthopedic doc didn’t treat me that way with my injury. They took an x ray and MRI and diagnosed the problem and recommended a course of treatment.
This is more like a 1980s choose your own adventure paperback of “guess what you should try next tk feel better”

This reminded me of the 1971 novel The Dice Man (not a novel I'd particularly recommend but I liked bits of it when I read it ages ago):

Now the curious reader will want to know what kind of an analyst I was. It so happens that I practiced non-directive therapy. For those not familiar with it, the analyst is passive, compassionate, non-interpretive, non-directing. More precisely, he resembles a redundant moron. For example, a session with a patient like Jenkins might go like this

JENKINS: 'I feel that no matter how hard I try I'm always going to fail; that some kind of internal mechanism always acts to screw up what I'm trying to do.'
[Pause] ANALYST: 'You feel that some part of you always forces you to fail.'
JENKINS: 'Yes. For example, that time when I had that date with that nice woman, really attractive - the librarian, you remember - and all I talked about at dinner and all evening was the New York Jets and what a great defensive secondary they have. I knew I should be talking books or asking her questions but I couldn't stop myself.'
ANALYST: 'You feel that some part of you consciously ruined the potential relationship with that girl:
JENKINS: 'And that job with Wessen, Wessen and Woof. I could have had it. But I took a month's vacation in Jamaica when I know they'd be wanting an interview! 'I see.'
'What do you make of it all, Doctor? I suppose it's masochistic.'
'You think it might be masochistic! 'I don't know. What do you think?'
'You aren't certain if it's masochistic but you do know that you often do things which are self-destructive.'
'That's right. That's right. And yet I don't have any suicidal tendencies. Except in those dreams. Throwing myself under a herd of hippopotamuses. Or 'potami. Setting myself on fire in front of Wessen, Wessen and Woof. But I keep goofing up real opportunities.'
'Although you never consciously think of suicide you have dreamed about it.'
'Yes. But that's normal. Everybody does crazy things in dreams.'
'You feel that your dreaming of self-destructive acts is normal because...'


The intelligent reader gets the picture. The effect of non-directive therapy is to encourage the patient to speak more and more frankly, to gain total confidence in the non-threatening, totally accepting clod who's curing him, and eventually to diagnose and resolve his own conflicts, with old thirty-five dollars-an-hour echoing away through it all behind the couch.
And it works. It works precisely as well as every other tested form of psychotherapy. It works sometimes and fails at others, and its successes and failures are identical with other analysts' successes and failures. Of course at times the dialogue resembles a comedy routine. My patient the second hour, that morning was a hulking heir to a small fortune who had the build of a professional wrestler and the mentality of a professional wrestler."
 
Last edited:

Gonz

₲‹›Ŋʑ
#8
After many years of starting and stopping therapy, I’ve found one that is very solution-focused. This is the first I’ve felt like I could work with. Most have been exactly as you described.

I understand that it’s a complex issue, and that not everything she suggests will work quickly or at all. I can live with that. But I really appreciate finally having one that actually works with me to find things to actually do that might help, rather than just asking question after question.
 

Please Donate to Help Keep SF Running

Total amount
$45.00
Goal
$255.00
Top