• IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT: Please read THIS THREAD about a rebrand for SF.

Ideas & Opinions Is a diagnosis helpful?

IRE1992

SF Supporter
#1
I've now been seeing my current therapist (A psychotherapist not a psychiatrist)
for about a year fortnightly this hasn't been continuous.
Measurable progress has been made in terms of increasing social engagement
and reducing anxiety levels.
However I've never been told what her diagnosis is - we mainly just focus on
grounding techniques and CBT style thought restructuring.
(My current exercise is to record cognitive biases throughout the week.)

Pros of this:
  • Focus on altering behaviors and increasing functioning rather than mulling over what category I'm in.
  • Don't identify too much with whatever my disorder is as this can be problematic - i.e. blaming everything on a single disorder.
  • Label could be demotivating/stigmatizing in the case of enduring problems like personality disorders.

Cons:
  • Easier to lookup information outside of sessions or find support group if I can label what I have.
  • Easier to transfer to other services/help if can categorize.
  • Label could serve as mental tool help section/box off my problems from other aspects of life.

What to others think?
 

MisterBGone

~\_✅`,')
SF Supporter
#2
Have you tried asking her about it? And see if she gives you her reason(s) for why, she has not offered one? For the record - I've heard of others doing this as well (not giving their patients one). So you are not alone! Sometimes, maybe it depends on the diagnosis? Especially if we're going to hyperfocus, or get fixated on the wrong thing, or things, the negative attributes or characteristics, and things we may read on the internet. But this is all just wild speculation, at best... Other problem is: well, there's a number, but that just leads to a number more, and maybe we don't want to go sprinting down those pathways just yet? If ever... Ha! Being Self-deprecating here (is all). Wishing you luck, with this.
 

MisterBGone

~\_✅`,')
SF Supporter
#3
To answer your question: personally, while I feel it is (somewhat) "helpful." It is also just a frame of reference, or more of a reference point for me. As there are many other factors that play into it, than simply settling everything with a name. For it's hard to fit neatly & perfectly inside of one box. Lots of nuances, and then there is the individuality of it all. I think where it can be educational is when you get diagnosed with something, that you know very little about. But even then, all that does is get you up to speed with where others are at. And not always a whole lot close r to the solving of one's conflict/s or problem(s) - shall we say? So it's a mixed bag, or it can be. You can also see, from their point of view--where it would or might be advantageous, or not, to give one of their patients that "label," of a diagnosis, or it wouldn't (be beneficial for or from their end).
 
#4
You've identified some good pros and cons.

In some cases, having a diagnosis can help you qualify for certain government services, make more treatment options available to you, or give you and others an explanation that helps give an understanding of what you're experiencing.

About the last point, this is something that can help counteract negative judgments or ease social relationships.
 

LumberJack

Huggy Bear 🐻 u r warned!
SF Supporter
#7
For me it’s helpful to have a diagnosis. My therapist does not like to dwell on diagnosis so much as what we do in the present, and I appreciate her reasoning.

However, for me having an idea of what I should do to feel better is important. So like having a diagnosis that is treated the same as another with similar symptoms, is pointless IMHO. However, I have symptoms that overlap between a few conditions. The need for medication and how I would best develop my coping skills is dependent on whether I have one or the other.

Full disclosure: I have asked my therapist repeatedly if I have a personality disorder. She has wisely demurred to date. I know in the back of my mind, that I am looking for an “out” with respect to working in therapy. I mean, if I am borderline or whatever, then gee, it’s not my fault, I can’t help being who I am! And when I feel like being cruel to myself, I can use my diagnosis to serve as evidence that I’m hopeless. But neither are true. So diagnostic information is really important for making care decisions, but not for helping the patient. Just my thoughts.

I think that is the same thing as what you said, but in a narrative form instead of lists.
 
Last edited:

IRE1992

SF Supporter
#9
Thanks for all the replies - I think I lean towards @LumberJack 's point about personality disorders as in my case it would cause me to feel hopeless due to how difficult they are manage (Those that aren't BPD have little research).
To honest if she thought giving me a diagnosis would help she would given it by now - so I think I'll continue as is for now.
 

MisterBGone

~\_✅`,')
SF Supporter
#10
Thanks for all the replies - I think I lean towards @LumberJack 's point about personality disorders as in my case it would cause me to feel hopeless due to how difficult they are manage (Those that aren't BPD have little research).
To honest if she thought giving me a diagnosis would help she would given it by now - so I think I'll continue as is for now.
Sometimes, too... they like to take their time, when trying to establish a diagnosis. Whether or not this is the case for you, I could not say. Some prefer to gather more details / or intelligence (evidence), as it were~ until or before. Another potential issue for any that is given to anyone, and this may have already been mentioned by you or somebody else. Is that it can bring about, or cause you to actually feed into the symptoms. If you think, "Well? If I have such & such. Then according to the diagnostic features, I should be doing this." Glad you've found a good way of looking at it for now. And hope it continues to go well for you!
 

Harmony

Well-Known member
SF Supporter
#11
I think certain diagnoses run the risk of self-stigmatization. For example, someone may have been given a diagnosis of bpd. It's well documented that the prognosis for personality disorders is not very good, however, just like many disorders they occur on a continuum and that never seems to be accounted for in much of the literature thereby running the risk of cultivating a defeatist attitude.
I also find ASPD problematic in diagnosing but for vastly different reasons.
 

Survivorist

Black sheep of my family....
#12
I think there are different forms of asking the same question. Maybe one will make the thing clearer?
  • advantages and disadvantages
  • assets and liabilities
  • costs and benefits
  • gains and losses
  • opportunities and obstacles
  • strengths and weaknesses
  • positives and negatives
  • benefits and disadvantages
  • benefits and disbenefits
  • benefits and detriments
  • benefits and drawbacks
  • benefits and risks
  • highs and lows
  • good and bad
  • merits and drawbacks
I personally think, you got better. Why, does not matter - just enjoy your progress.
 

MisterBGone

~\_✅`,')
SF Supporter
#13
It they’re not passing pills 💊 or prescribing meds, @IRE1992 - (which I believe you’d clarified that they were not). Then I don’t think it makes nearly as much of a difference…
 

Ash600

Of dust and shadows
SF Creative
SF Supporter
#14
Diagnoses can come with so many pros and cons attached. As to whether it's helpful or not is dependant upon any particular given situation which seems to have been already established judging from some of the replies posted on here. Though I am curious in the view that "if they are not passing pills or prescribing meds, then it doesn't make nearly as much of a difference." Non-pharmacological interventions following on from a diagnosis can produce beneficial results.


The obvious answer would be that if a diagnosis can lead to a postive outcome, then it's helpful and something that which one can but hope for.
 

SillyOldBear

Teddy Bears Rule! 🐻
Staff Alumni
#15
I've not found a diagnosis necessary for ne. The purpose of a diagnosis is to help understanding and inform treatment. A lot of diagnosis are kinda interchangeable- with very similar symptoms.

The question is - will having a diagnosis help you?
@IRE1992 If you have ever read any of the diagnostic Manuel used by *pdocs you will see how similar the symptoms are between illnesses. I am not at all sure a diagnosis would help that much. It can certainly be confusing making one.
 

PrincessPure

Well-Known Member
#16
My previous doctor said that in the new field of psychiatry they dont have lables for diagnosis, they just deal with people. Kind of a relief to me. The mental illnesses which have been defined have so many interchangable symptoms its crazy. Its maybe better not to have a lable on you.
 

snails

Useless currently
#18
It depends doesn't it. Like being diagnosed autistic helped me and also harmed me. It helps me understand myself and my identity but with no follow up support it is just difficult. And there is a large part of feeling defective. Because it's all I've ever heard. It's probably different to a mh diagnosis but not necessarily to a severe enduring diagnosis. At the end of the day I think it really really matters what you think and what support is in place to handle any diagnosis.
 

mosaic hearts

I am we - working hard at getting it together.🦋🐻
#20
I've now been seeing my current therapist (A psychotherapist not a psychiatrist)
for about a year fortnightly this hasn't been continuous.
Measurable progress has been made in terms of increasing social engagement
and reducing anxiety levels.
However I've never been told what her diagnosis is - we mainly just focus on
grounding techniques and CBT style thought restructuring.
(My current exercise is to record cognitive biases throughout the week.)

Pros of this:
  • Focus on altering behaviors and increasing functioning rather than mulling over what category I'm in.
  • Don't identify too much with whatever my disorder is as this can be problematic - i.e. blaming everything on a single disorder.
  • Label could be demotivating/stigmatizing in the case of enduring problems like personality disorders.

Cons:
  • Easier to lookup information outside of sessions or find support group if I can label what I have.
  • Easier to transfer to other services/help if can categorize.
  • Label could serve as mental tool help section/box off my problems from other aspects of life.

What to others think?
I've now been seeing my current therapist (A psychotherapist not a psychiatrist)
for about a year fortnightly this hasn't been continuous.
Measurable progress has been made in terms of increasing social engagement
and reducing anxiety levels.
However I've never been told what her diagnosis is - we mainly just focus on
grounding techniques and CBT style thought restructuring.
(My current exercise is to record cognitive biases throughout the week.)

Pros of this:
  • Focus on altering behaviors and increasing functioning rather than mulling over what category I'm in.
  • Don't identify too much with whatever my disorder is as this can be problematic - i.e. blaming everything on a single disorder.
  • Label could be demotivating/stigmatizing in the case of enduring problems like personality disorders.

Cons:
  • Easier to lookup information outside of sessions or find support group if I can label what I have.
  • Easier to transfer to other services/help if can categorize.
  • Label could serve as mental tool help section/box off my problems from other aspects of life.

What to others think?
I think past a certain point of time or development or therapy diagnosis really means jack shit.

Like Im very likely someone with PTSD but never been diagnosed. Do I care fo verify? What good would that do?
For me, a diagnosis was helpful in that it explained what was going on for me & provided a framework for treatment. I can understand why some people are hesitant to embrace one, though.
 

Please Donate to Help Keep SF Running

Total amount
$45.00
Goal
$255.00
Top