The Buddha answered along the lines of āTry it out. If it leads to less suffering, keep it. Else, discard it.ā
I've read that reference as well, and they're certainly not grasping it. They're just reading all the scriptures and regurgitating them, parrot fashion. Then convincing themselves they'll reach Nirvanna, where they're not born into life anymore.
But again trying to control what I call consciousness, and what other people call the soul, is about as much use as trying to tie your shoe laces up in a revolving doorway, it's nice to think that when we're dead that's the end of all the suffering, but consciousness is un-killable, it only attaches itself to life to experience life, and though I could go into my own opinions of why this is, I'd probably crash the server as it will use up all their bandwidth with words.
This is what I was trying to get at on the Buddhist forum, but they're so busy arguing over what is right and wrong in the suttas, I ended up falling out with them all, I'll let the dust settle and go back in later this year! I may even self promote myself to a Bhante lol.
I only learned about the Buddha last year when I came across a stone ornament in a garden with birds perched on it. That was the only thing that caught my attention. And it was then that I read about how he lived in a wealthy family in a palace, having everything he could ever wish for. The servants kept all the flowers fresh, and he was sheltered from old age and death, never having a day without getting whatever he wanted. Yet, he walked away from all of that and spent six years seeking the truth of life, or enlightenment, as they call it.
The first thing he saw when he left the palace was an old man, and that threw him completely. He spent six years in what sounds like a complete nightmare, becoming so thin that they say his eyes were sunk so far back into his skull they looked like two deep wells.
And yet, he never went back to where he had everything in the palace; he kept going. It's a bit like that famous Winston Churchill quote: "If you're going through hell, keep going." And the Buddha did keep going.
He ended up sitting under a Bodhi tree for seven days, close to death, and only then did he have a premonition that he needed to eat. And that was his enlightenment. The first words he said to the other three who was with him were, "I'm hungry; let's get something to eat." It's said they were so disillusioned by his comment that they left him there and then, as they had expected him to say something profound about his enlightenment.
The scripture (or suttas) were written 500 years after The Buddhas death, and this is what Buddhists learn off by heart. The Buddha never even wrote them, yet I find it odd that they were written at the time Jesus was said to be about.
I would show this by an illustration.
Please do, I'll save it as a jpeg and post it on their forum when I return back there!