I'm sorry lane, this is all just so asinine to me! Why is he (being) like this? Is he the one who stays/lives with you? Or does he see you more often than he does she? Maybe that's got something to do with it then. That he downplays your pain, and you side in all of this, and overemphasizes and sympathizes with hers. As it is heightened, then in his head, and in his mind. Which of course, brings it nowhere more near reality. The bottom line is: you know the deal. And you know the truth. What is real. And how it is. At the end of the day, that is all you can accept. Is that you have done every-thing you can to reach out for quite some time. That she hasn't returned serve, as much or nearly so often as you, is on her totally, completely, and entirely. He is just casting the fault on you & your shoulders, for whatever reason? Out of frustration. Or maybe it is that he feels he has more control, or ability to influence you, on your end, than he does she on hers (if she is still that bitter, or whatever). Anyway, sorry he hurt your feelings only thing I can say is that a very important detail about him was revealed by you in the beginning. That he is blunt, direct, and frank. When people are this way, on the one hand you appreciate getting more information (hopefully truthful, but in this case it's at least as he believes it, in the here & now anyway, who knows what he'd say deep down inside...) but on the other, they can do a lot of damage, with this abrasiveness, and seeming(ly) lack of 'tact,' in their delivery, and their approaches. So yes, that was a lot to take in & to process all at once, and it is no wonder that you broke down then. Give yourself credit for continuing to put the effort in after all of this time when many other Mothers by now would have said, "Good Bye," & some of them, 'good riddance!'