It does get a bad rap, but I still think you're nuts for ranking it so high! But it is very enjoyable. It's too bad it got canceled when it did, they were starting to embrace long-form storytelling in a unique way and find their voice. Season 3 was one long storyline, and season 4 was a lot of two- and three-part episodes, which was fun. I think Season 5 would have explored the formation of the Federation, too.