Well to be fair historically critics have never liked horror movies, even stuff like The Shining which is now a critical darling originally received poor critical reception and that was from a critically acclaimed director, so low-budget stuff like this normally got it worse, if you review the history of most classic horror movies they were generally poorly received.
So yeah when it comes to horror in particular it's good to skeptic of the critics, it's only in recent history and by that I mean the decade that just ended that horror movies have started to received good initial critical reception, and the problem with movies like Night of the Lepus is that even if it has advocates it'll mostly be hipsters that are enjoying it ironically and therefore it's unlikely to receive good revisionist critical reception.